Devolution

Should more power be given away?

50
588
712
134

Devolution is the transfer of powers from the UK Parliament in Westminster to the Welsh and Northern Irish assemblies in Cardiff and Belfast, and the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh. In 1998, Parliament passed 3 devolution Acts of Parliament: the Scotland Act 1998; the Northern Ireland Act 1998; and the Government of Wales Act 1998, all of which made significant changes to the UK’s uncodified constitution. It was decided after the recent Scottish referendum that more powers are to be devolved. What does this mean for the UK Parliament? There is much debate surrounding the English question – Should MPs with seats in Scotland, Northern Ireland or Wales continue to be allowed to vote on legislation and other matters in the UK Parliament in Westminster that will only affect people in England?

More >

Hacking the Content
Refining the Content
Preparation
Constitutional Convention
Our new Constitution

Filters

Tags

Tags

View More

Status Labels

Status Labels

Top Contributors

  1. Michael Ward
    1605 pts
  2. Harry Blain
    1274 pts
  3. Debra Storr
    1200 pts
  4. John Z
    1075 pts
  5. steveg33
    902 pts

View leaderboard

Sort by

I’ve only just joined this project, so I’ve been trying to catch up. But reading the posts on Devolution, my impression is that the debate’s already so polarised that it’s effectively blocked.   On the one hand, there are those who believe in “English votes for English laws” and, on the other, there are those who think that if the Scots and the Welsh have what are in effect regional assemblies, people in England should have them too.   My guess is that the polarisation among...

Alastair Bruton
by Alastair Bruton
6 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 15
Alastair Bruton

It sounds like a fundamentally simple thing to say, but devolution  needs to come from the grass roots up. We've seen during the course of the coalition government, various devolution packages here and there but the whole system is fundamentally flawed as central government has decided which areas should get devolution and what they should get.  Here in Cornwall there is a clear appetite for devolution and an apparent unwillingness for central government to address these issues. Despite,...

cernyw
by cernyw
5 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 16
cernyw
by
cernyw

The 1707 act of Union is dead in all but name.  Significantly it stated that here should be one UK government to represent the UK.  Now we have three, in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.  Ministers from these institutions can, and have, represented the whole of the UK in the EU. In addition that Act stated that all parts of the Union should have equal opportunities and benefits.  Clearly that is no longer the case with free or subsidised tertiary education everywhere in the UK except...

Priscilla Cullen
by Priscilla Cullen
11 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 48
Priscilla Cullen

It's the last week of the first phase of the project and thanks everyone for your contributions so far. The devolution debate in the UK is often hindered by differing interpretations of the main underlying principle of devolving power. Mainly, is the principle of devolution about bringing more power and decision making to a local level or is it about reinforcing the national or sub-national identities within the UK? A big aspect of this debate is whether England should be regionalised or...

Michael Ward
by Michael Ward
4 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 8
Michael Ward

Suggested constitution clause: 'Central Government spending must be on a basis which is fair to all regions of the [UK].  As a general rule, amounts spent by Central Government in each region must be on the basis that average per-capita expenditure is the same in all regions of the [UK].  Expenditure may however be varied where this is justified by evidence of greater or lesser needs of different regions.'   Idea behind the draft clause: The Barnett Formula should be scrapped and...

Ian Smith
by Ian Smith
15 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 17
Ian Smith

With the continuing compromises and back-door politics surrounding the SNP and the mainstream parties of Westminster over devolution max or national independence, why not draft up a federal constitution to safeguard the democratic rights of every citizen wherever he lives and to whichever nationality he identifies himself. With a federal constitution we can allocate the correct resources, budget and taxation levels to each region whilst offering equal representation in a federal parliament....

FederalBritain
by FederalBritain
6 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 17
FederalBritain

in the Greater Manchester discussion, I've argued that devolution is not real unless the tax raising powers follow.   This comes from the experience in Scotland where the Scottish Parliament was set up with a fairly broad range of functions but very little control of the budget.  The tax raising power given was to vary the standard rate of income tax by 3p. the power has never been used as the money raised would be so small in comparison to the impacts.   But that means it's easy for a...

Debra Storr
by Debra Storr
12 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 15
Debra Storr

The regions of England have legitimate historic identities, some with their own ancient languages and customs, others with dialects still in common use. These identities will not be preserved or protected without recognition, and the idea of a unitary England is what prevents that recognition. I'll start by declaring that I've been pretty open about being in favour of regional devolution, but I've seen enough conflict over the subject of England in the context of devolution that it seems...

John Hackett
by John Hackett
9 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 18
John Hackett

It might be expected that the Federal Trust would welcome the willingness of politicians and commentators after the Scottish referendum to consider seriously what they describe as “federal” structures for the United Kingdom. There is however a strong possibility of entirely the “wrong sort” of federalism’s now commending itself to British policy-makers, particularly in England. Simply to label proposals as “federalist” in inspiration does not of itself guarantee either their correspondence...

The Federal Trust
by The Federal Trust
21 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 32
The Federal Trust

The Greater Manchester Referendum Campaign has, since early December, been criticising the absence of public consultation in the drawing up of plans for a "devo-manc" settlement, referred to in earlier posts.  The fear is that, without a referendum, much of the content of "devo-manc" is unaccountable and undemocratic. As "Mancunian Spring" put it: "So where do we go from here and how do we escape the clutches of an establishment devolution model attempting to maintain as much of the status...

Harry Blain
by Harry Blain
4 Votes
Voting closed
Comments 9
Harry Blain
Share